Experienced-attorney interviews are not law-school OCI. By the time you are in the room, your résumé has already done its job — the interview exists to answer three questions the document cannot: Can you do the work at the level we need? Will you actually move, and stay? And do we want you in the next office? Strong candidates lose offers by preparing for the wrong one of these.
This guide covers how to prepare for each, how firm and in-house processes differ, and how to turn the back half of the interview — your questions — into the part that closes the deal.
Know which conversation you are in
Firm interviews and in-house interviews screen for different things. A firm is underwriting whether you can generate and execute high-quality billable work and fit a specific group. An in-house team is underwriting judgment, business fluency, and whether you can operate without the infrastructure of a firm.
- At a firm: be ready to go deep on your matters, your practice area, and — at senior levels — your business and client relationships.
- In-house: be ready to talk about risk tradeoffs, working with non-lawyers, and how you prioritize when everything is "urgent."
- In both: have a clear, forward-looking answer for "why are you looking?" that is about where you are going, not what you are escaping.
Master the matter walk-through
The single most predictive moment in a senior interview is when you are asked to walk through a matter you handled. Interviewers use it to test depth, judgment, and how you think under questioning. Prepare two or three matters cold.
- Pick matters you can discuss without breaching confidentiality — anonymize parties and figures.
- Structure each: the situation, the stakes, your specific role, the key judgment calls, and the outcome.
- Be honest about what was hard and what you would do differently — it reads as senior, not weak.
- Expect follow-ups that probe the edges; the goal is to show how you reason, not to recite.
Prepare for the predictable questions
- Why are you exploring a move, and why now?
- Why this firm / this company specifically? (Generic answers end candidacies.)
- Walk me through your most complex matter.
- For partners: tell me about your book and how portable it is.
- In-house: describe a time you had to say no to the business — or find a way to yes.
- Where do you want your practice to be in five years?
Ask questions that signal seniority
The questions you ask are evaluated as closely as your answers. Thoughtful questions show you are assessing the opportunity like a professional weighing a long-term decision — not a candidate grateful to be considered.
- How does work get allocated, and how would mine flow in the first year?
- What does the path forward look like here, and what does success look like at 12 and 24 months?
- What is driving this hire — growth, a gap, succession?
- For in-house: how does Legal sit relative to the business, and who do I partner with most?
- What has made past hires into this group succeed or struggle?
Logistics and follow-through
- Research every interviewer and the group’s recent work before the call.
- For video interviews, test your setup, framing, and lighting in advance.
- Send a concise, specific thank-you note within 24 hours.
- Keep your recruiter informed after each round so they can manage timing and feedback on your behalf — never negotiate or chase directly while a recruiter is running the process.
The Offer Evaluation & Negotiation Guide
Once the interviews land an offer, this guide breaks down everything that is negotiable beyond base — and how to ask.
Get the Report →Have a question this guide didn’t answer?
Every situation is specific. For a confidential, no-pressure conversation about your career, talk to The Walker Group.
Start a Confidential Conversation